Shopify VAT Margin Scheme: Why It Does Not Work and What to Do Instead

If you sell second-hand goods through Shopify, whether that is jewellery, antiques, watches, or vintage items, you have probably discovered a frustrating gap: Shopify does not support the VAT Margin Scheme. Purpose-built VAT Margin Scheme software fills that gap while still letting you sell through your Shopify store.

There is no setting, no app, and no built-in workaround. Shopify applies standard VAT to every product, and there is no way to tell it to calculate VAT on your profit margin instead.

This guide explains why this is a problem, what dealers currently do to work around it, why those workarounds carry risk, and how to solve it properly.

The problem: Shopify and the VAT Margin Scheme are incompatible

The VAT Margin Scheme allows dealers of eligible second-hand goods to pay VAT only on the profit margin of each sale, the difference between what you paid for an item and what you sold it for, rather than on the full selling price.

For example, if you buy a vintage brooch for £200 and sell it for £350:

• With the margin scheme: VAT is calculated on the £150 margin = £25.00 (£150 ÷ 6)
• Without the margin scheme: VAT is calculated on the full £350 = £58.33 (£350 ÷ 6)

That is a saving of £33.33 on a single item. Across hundreds of transactions a year, the difference is substantial.

The problem is that Shopify has no concept of a “purchase price” for your products. It knows the selling price and the VAT rate, and that is all. It cannot calculate VAT on the margin because it does not know what the margin is.

What Shopify actually does

When you create a product in Shopify and assign it a VAT rate:

• Shopify charges the customer the full VAT amount on the selling price
• The order confirmation shows standard VAT
• Shopify’s tax reports calculate VAT on the full selling price
• There is no field for purchase price, no margin calculation, no stock book

This is fine for retailers selling new goods at standard VAT. It is completely inadequate for dealers of second-hand goods who are eligible for the margin scheme and legally entitled to use it.

The Shopify community knows this is a problem

Search the Shopify Community forums for “VAT Margin Scheme” and you will find threads going back years from frustrated dealers. The responses from Shopify’s support team are consistent: “Shopify doesn’t support this. You may want to look for a third-party app.”

The difficulty is that no adequate third-party app exists within Shopify’s ecosystem to solve this properly. The margin scheme requires item-level purchase price tracking, per-item margin calculations, and a detailed stock book, none of which Shopify’s product model supports.

What dealers currently do (and why it is risky)

Faced with Shopify’s limitations, dealers have developed various workarounds. All of them introduce risk.

Workaround 1: set VAT to zero on Shopify

Some dealers mark all their products as zero-rated or VAT-exempt on Shopify. The customer sees no VAT on their receipt. The dealer then calculates margin scheme VAT manually and accounts for it in their bookkeeping software (Xero, QuickBooks, or FreeAgent).

The risks:

• Your Shopify records show no VAT, but you are collecting and owing VAT on margins, so the records do not match
• If HMRC audits your Shopify data, it will appear that you are not charging VAT at all
• There is no digital link between the Shopify sale and the margin calculation
• Under Making Tax Digital, your income and expense records must be kept digitally with digital links between systems

Workaround 2: apply standard VAT and adjust in accounting

Other dealers let Shopify charge standard VAT, then create manual journal entries in their accounting software to reverse the standard VAT and replace it with margin scheme VAT.

The risks:

• Customers are overcharged VAT on their receipts (though they cannot reclaim it on second-hand goods, it is still incorrect)
• Every sale requires a manual adjustment, which is time-consuming and error-prone
• Journal entries are easily forgotten, especially during busy periods
• HMRC can question discrepancies between your point-of-sale records and VAT returns

Workaround 3: spreadsheets alongside Shopify

A third approach uses spreadsheets to maintain a parallel stock book. The dealer enters purchase prices, sale prices, and margin calculations in a spreadsheet, while using Shopify purely as a storefront.

The risks:

• Double data entry (Shopify and the spreadsheet) invites errors
• The spreadsheet is not linked to Shopify, so data can drift apart
• Spreadsheets are difficult to audit and easy to corrupt
• Under Making Tax Digital, spreadsheets must have digital links to your submission software, and most do not

The common thread

Every workaround shares the same fundamental problem: you are maintaining two separate systems that do not talk to each other. One system handles selling (Shopify), and a completely different system handles VAT compliance (spreadsheets, accounting software, or paper records). The gap between them is where errors happen.

Why getting it wrong matters

The VAT Margin Scheme is not optional once you have elected to use it. HMRC requires:

• A stock book, in written or electronic form, recording purchase price, sale price, and margin for every eligible item
• Purchase and sales invoices that meet the margin scheme invoicing conditions
• Correct VAT calculations on each transaction
• Proper identification of which items qualify for the margin scheme (not all do)

Making Tax Digital for Income Tax sits alongside these rather than inside them. It does not add a VAT record-keeping condition; it obliges in-scope businesses to keep digital income and expense records and send quarterly updates.

Getting it wrong can result in:

• Penalties for incorrect VAT returns, which HMRC charges based on the amount of tax underpaid and whether the error was careless or deliberate
• Interest on underpaid VAT, if your manual calculations understated your VAT liability
• Loss of margin scheme eligibility, since repeated non-compliance can result in HMRC withdrawing your right to use the scheme
• Time-consuming audits, because inconsistent records between Shopify and your VAT returns are a red flag for HMRC compliance checks

The irony is that most dealers use the margin scheme because it reduces their VAT bill. But if your record-keeping does not support the calculations, HMRC can assess you at standard rates, wiping out the benefit entirely.

How GemJam solves the Shopify margin scheme problem

GemJam was built specifically for dealers of unique, second-hand goods. It handles the parts that Shopify cannot, then syncs your listings to Shopify so you can keep selling through your online store.

How it works

1. Add items in GemJam. Enter the purchase price, supplier details, item description, photographs, and provenance. GemJam tracks everything HMRC requires.

2. GemJam calculates the margin. When you record a sale, the margin and the margin scheme VAT are worked out automatically for the items you have flagged as margin scheme. No spreadsheets, no manual calculations.

3. Sync to Shopify. GemJam pushes your product listings, including titles, descriptions, images, and prices, directly to your Shopify store. Your customers browse and buy on Shopify as normal.

4. Sell through Shopify. When a customer purchases through your Shopify store, you record the sale in GemJam. The margin calculation and stock book update happen automatically.

5. Report with confidence. GemJam produces the reports you need for your VAT returns, with complete per-item margin calculations and a digital stock book that satisfies HMRC.

What this means for your business

• Your inventory, VAT calculations, and Shopify listings all live in one system
• You add an item once in GemJam and it appears on Shopify automatically, so there is no double data entry
• Margin scheme calculations are automatic and auditable
• Your stock book is digital, your records have digital links, and your data is ready for Making Tax Digital
• You do not have to abandon your Shopify store; GemJam works alongside it

Step by step: using GemJam alongside Shopify

Here is how to set up GemJam to work with your Shopify store:

Step 1: set up your GemJam account

Sign up for GemJam and configure your business details, including your VAT registration and margin scheme preferences.

Step 2: connect your Shopify store

Link your Shopify store to GemJam through the integration settings. GemJam will sync with your Shopify product catalogue.

Step 3: add your inventory

Enter your current stock into GemJam, including purchase prices and supplier details. For items already listed on Shopify, GemJam can match and link them.

Step 4: list new items through GemJam

When you acquire new stock, add it to GemJam first. Enter the purchase details, upload photographs, and write your description. Then publish the listing to Shopify directly from GemJam.

Step 5: record sales

When an item sells, whether through Shopify, at a fair, or through a private sale, record the sale in GemJam. The margin calculation, stock book update, and VAT tracking all happen automatically.

Step 6: run your VAT reports

At the end of each VAT period, GemJam produces a summary of your margin scheme transactions, including the total VAT due. Use this to complete your VAT return with confidence.

Making Tax Digital is coming. From April 2026, many sole trader dealers will need to keep digital records and submit quarterly updates to HMRC. Read our complete guide to Making Tax Digital for second-hand goods dealers →

What about shipping charges, card fees, and insurance?

A common question from dealers is whether costs like delivery charges, payment processing fees, or insurance affect the margin scheme calculation. The answer depends on who charges what to whom.

Costs that form part of the margin

HMRC defines the selling price as everything you receive for the goods, whether from the buyer or a third party, including incidental expenses directly linked to the sale. The purchase side works from the other direction: your purchase price is the total price on the margin scheme purchase invoice, and HMRC’s condition for a self-billed invoice is the “total price paid”, and it adds that you must not add any other costs to this price. So the test on a cost is not what kind of cost it is, but whether it sits inside that invoiced total. These are the cases dealers ask about:

• Transport and delivery charged to the buyer form part of your selling price and are included in the margin calculation. Delivery your supplier bills on the same purchase invoice is inside your purchase price; delivery invoiced separately by a courier you engaged is not.
• Packaging costs charged to the buyer are part of the selling price; packaging on the supplier’s purchase invoice is part of the purchase price.
• Commission works in both directions. At auction, whether the buyer’s premium is part of your purchase price depends on how the auctioneer invoiced it: a VAT-inclusive premium inside a single total with no VAT shown separately is part of the purchase price, whereas VAT shown separately on the premium makes it a standard-rated service, with the VAT on it potentially recoverable as input tax under the normal rules instead. Never both. If you sell through an auctioneer using the Auctioneers’ Scheme, HMRC’s rule is that the auctioneer’s purchase price is the hammer price less any commission charged to the seller, and the selling price is the hammer price plus charges for services to the buyer. Some online platforms (such as 1stDibs) act as intermediaries who sit between you and the buyer, arrange shipping, and handle customer service, which makes them more like an agent than a simple storefront. In these cases, their sales commission may reduce your selling price for margin scheme purposes. The treatment depends on the specific contractual arrangement, so check with your accountant if you sell through a platform that acts as an intermediary.
• Insurance you charge the buyer as part of the sale is included in the selling price, and insurance the supplier bills on the purchase invoice is included in the purchase price. However, if the insurance is provided by a third party and the buyer arranges it separately, it is not part of your selling price, so account for it outside the margin scheme.

Example: You buy a vintage watch for £400 and the seller charges you £15 for insured postage on the same invoice, giving an invoice total of £415. That is your purchase price. You sell it for £750 and charge the buyer £12 for delivery. Your selling price is £762. The margin is £762 − £415 = £347, and the VAT due is £347 ÷ 6 = £57.83.

Costs that do not form part of the margin

Business overheads and selling costs cannot be deducted from the margin. The margin scheme taxes the difference between what you paid for an item and what you sold it for, not your overall profit. This means you cannot reduce your margin by subtracting:

• Card processing fees, such as those from Stripe, PayPal, or Shopify Payments, are a cost of doing business, not part of the margin calculation
• Platform fees, such as Shopify subscription costs, eBay listing fees, or similar charges, cannot be deducted from the selling price
• Repair and restoration costs cannot be added to your purchase price: if you restore an antique before selling it, that cost is not part of the margin calculation
• Storage, rent, and other overheads are general business costs

The distinction between a platform fee and agent’s commission matters here. Shopify charges you a monthly subscription and a payment processing percentage; these are clearly business overheads. But platforms like 1stDibs or auction houses that act as intermediaries between you and the buyer may charge commission that affects the margin calculation because they are functioning as agents rather than simply providing a storefront. If you are unsure how a platform’s fees should be treated, check with your accountant; the answer depends on whether the platform acts as your agent or simply as a service provider.

Why this catches people out

Many dealers assume that if Shopify or PayPal takes a 2-3% cut, they can subtract that from the selling price before calculating the margin. You cannot. The selling price is what the customer pays you, before any fees are deducted by payment processors or platforms. Similarly, you cannot add repair costs to inflate your purchase price and reduce the margin.

GemJam handles this correctly: for items you have flagged as margin scheme, it works out the margin from the purchase price you recorded and the selling price when the item sells, without deducting business overheads or platform fees that are not part of the margin scheme calculation.

Who this applies to

The VAT Margin Scheme is available to VAT-registered dealers, and eligibility turns on the goods and on how you acquired them: second-hand stock the scheme covers, bought with no VAT charged or reclaimable. Buying from a private individual or a non-VAT-registered seller is the usual route in, not proof on its own. Common examples include:

• Jewellery dealers buying from private sellers, estates, and auctions
• Antique dealers sourcing from house clearances and private collections
• Watch dealers purchasing pre-owned timepieces
• Art dealers acquiring works from private owners
• Vintage and retro dealers buying from markets and private sellers

Buying from a VAT-registered business does not rule the scheme out by itself. What matters is whether VAT was charged: if the seller invoiced you with VAT you could reclaim, that item falls under standard VAT rules, but another dealer selling to you under their own margin scheme charges no VAT, and that purchase still qualifies. GemJam tracks which items qualify and which do not, so you always know which scheme applies to each sale.

Join the GemJam waiting list and get your first month free →

Frequently asked questions

Does Shopify support the VAT Margin Scheme?

No. Shopify does not have a native VAT Margin Scheme option. It applies standard VAT to all products, which means you cannot use Shopify alone to calculate VAT on the profit margin as required by the margin scheme. You need a separate system to handle margin scheme calculations and record-keeping.

Can I set VAT to zero on Shopify and handle margin scheme VAT separately?

Some dealers set VAT to zero or mark products as VAT-exempt on Shopify, then calculate margin scheme VAT manually in their accounting software. While this avoids charging customers the wrong VAT amount, it creates compliance risks: your Shopify records will not match your VAT returns, there is no audit trail linking sales to margin calculations, and manual processes are prone to errors.

What is the VAT Margin Scheme for second-hand goods?

The VAT Margin Scheme allows dealers of eligible second-hand goods to pay VAT only on their profit margin (the difference between the purchase price and selling price) rather than the full selling price. This can significantly reduce VAT liability. Eligible goods include jewellery, antiques, watches, art, and other unique items, provided you acquired them with no VAT charged or reclaimable. Buying from a non-VAT-registered individual is the usual route in, not proof on its own.

Do I need to keep a stock book for the VAT Margin Scheme?

Yes. HMRC requires dealers using the VAT Margin Scheme to maintain a stock book, in written or electronic form, for every eligible item. The full statutory list runs wider than the purchase price, selling price, and margin: it also takes in a unique stock number, the purchase and sale dates, the purchase invoice number (unless you made out the purchase invoice yourself) and the sales invoice number, the seller and buyer names, a description of the item, and the VAT due on the margin. Making Tax Digital for Income Tax does not change that rule, but if you are in scope it separately requires digital records of your business income and expenses, which is much easier to satisfy if the stock book is already electronic.

Can I sell on Shopify and still use the VAT Margin Scheme?

Yes, but not through Shopify alone. You need a separate inventory management system that handles margin scheme calculations and record-keeping. GemJam does this and syncs your product listings to Shopify, so you get the benefit of selling through your Shopify store while maintaining full margin scheme compliance.

How does GemJam work with Shopify for the margin scheme?

GemJam manages your inventory with built-in VAT Margin Scheme calculations. When you add items to GemJam, it tracks purchase prices, calculates margins on sale, and maintains the digital stock book HMRC requires. GemJam then syncs your product listings — including titles, descriptions, images, and prices — directly to your Shopify store. You sell through Shopify; GemJam handles the VAT.

What happens if I get the VAT Margin Scheme wrong on my Shopify sales?

Getting margin scheme calculations wrong can result in HMRC penalties, interest on underpaid VAT, and potential audits. Common mistakes include applying standard VAT instead of margin scheme VAT, failing to maintain adequate records, and incorrectly claiming items under the margin scheme. The more manual your process, the higher the risk of errors.

---

For official guidance on the VAT Margin Scheme, visit GOV.UK: VAT Margin Schemes, Using the global accounting VAT margin scheme, and the force-of-law conditions in VAT tertiary legislation: margin schemes. VAT Notice 718 was withdrawn on 23 December 2021. For Making Tax Digital, see GOV.UK: Use Making Tax Digital for Income Tax.

GemJam is inventory management software built specifically for UK dealers of jewellery, antiques, watches, and luxury goods, with built-in VAT Margin Scheme compliance and Shopify integration.